Boeheim Should NOT Be Fired…And Other Thoughts

Dennis Nett/Syracuse.com
By Zach Lowe

A devastating day.  ESPN Outside the Lines aired the audiotape conversation between Bernie Fine’s wife, Laurie, and his accuser, Bobby Davis.  A third accuser emerged. Bernie Fine was fired. Some started the clock on when Jim Boeheim would join him. Boeheim releases a well-worded statement agreeing with the decision to fire Bernie and apologizing for his initial comments.

The twists are coming faster than I can type. As I have previously written here, this entire situation hits close to home. My thoughts are like marbles spilt onto a hardwood floor – unbearably loud and impossible to corral. So as I work to gather them, here are some thoughts on this awful day…

Bernie Fine - There just doesn’t seem to be any plausible context in which the conversation between his wife Laurie and Bobby Davis does anything but bolster the allegations against Bernie. More is sure to come out but this is enough for now. Firing him was the right move. He is entitled to his day in court, but the court of public opinion may have already ruled.

Laurie Fine - The nonchalant manor in which she discussed such monstrous activities is crazy.

Head Coach Jim Boeheim – Based on the known facts, Boeheim should not be fired. His initial reaction to the allegations against Bernie Fine were bold. And with the release of the audiotape conversation between Laurie Fine and Davis, Boeheim’s remarks look very insensitive to say the least. But there is zero evidence thus far that Boeheim was aware of the alleged abuse. When those allegations against his friend of 50 years were made public, he acted as one would expect one to act in such a situation. Does that make it ok? No. Boeheim has and should continue to apologize – to Davis, to Lang, to victims of abuse. But does he deserve to be fired? No.

Syracuse Chancellor Nancy Cantor – Her letter to SU alumni was spot on. Her handling of this crisis has been flawless. She is working admirably to ensure justice is served and the integrity of the institution is maintained.

ESPN – Why was the audiotape not released with the initial report? Because they were waiting for the voice on the tape to be positively identified as that of Laurie Fine? Bullshit. They had eight years to do that. The worldwide leader seems to be more interested in ratings than it is in journalistic integrity.  There is surely more to come from this story. But we may have to wait until each Sunday morning to learn what.

ESPN’s Dana O’Neil – Why is she continuing with the false equivalency between Syracuse and Penn State? Our exchange on Twitter:

O’Neil: “It is unbelievable to witness how the alleged actions of two men can cause two powerful universities to crumble so swiftly.”

Me: @dgoneil1 How is Syracuse crumbling?

O’Neil: Pretty painful stuff there right now, no? RT @ottosarmydotcom: @dgoneil1 How is Syracuse crumbling?

Me: @dgoneil1 Very painful. But your comparison to PSU is once again unfounded. PSU failed as an institution. No evidence of that at ‘Cuse.

I’m sure I think and feel more. But no appetite to type it up. Feel free to share your sporadic thoughts, as well.

You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.

6 Responses to “Boeheim Should NOT Be Fired…And Other Thoughts”

  1. The Ghost of Darwin's Past says:

    Just can’t see how you fire Boeheim over his comments. As long as he did not have any knowledge of the situation, his actions did nothing to contribute to the molestation of children. Insensitive comments – yes. Fireable? Absolutely not.

  2. Howie Brown says:

    I with both the sentiments of this article and the post by Ghosts.

    My question is this: why is no one talking about the sexual relationship between Davis and LAURIE Fine when he was 18!?!??!?!

    http://thebiglead.com/index.php/2011/11/27/bernie-fines-wife-knew-about-the-possibility-of-abuse-and-had-a-sexual-relationship-with-the-accuser-also/

  3. Jeff says:

    Did ESPN turn over the tape to the police in 2003? Isn’t that their moral obligation and more analogous to the Penn State situation where Paterno had information and did not act on it? How is this not getting played up in the media?

  4. DUANY BROTHERS says:

    ESPN better pray that no abuse occurred after 2002-2003 (when, I think, ESPN had the tape of Lori FIne)

    If abuse happened after they had the tape and they had this type of evidence and did not give to any type of authority, police, university officials, etc… then they are guilty of aiding the crime.

  5. Excuse me Boeheim, I speak Brazilian says:

    This whole situation makes me sick on several levels and the trial-by-media is frustrating. If abuse occurred, then it should be handled under the letter of the law. If the allegations prove to be false, then a whole lot of people look like jack-asses and the program is still tarnished. It’s a lose lose.

    My personal opinion? The truth is somewhere in the middle. The Fine family obviously has some pretty big skeletons in their closet, but the timing of the allegations is beyond suspect, from all three accusers.

    The fact that this might roll up to Boeheim is stupid and troubling. Yes he made insensitive comments, which he’s since apologized for, but he’s a bystander in this whole sick debacle. If nothing else, his very candid initial comments clearly demonstrate he really didn’t know of any wrong-doing by any member of his coaching staff.

    On a brighter note, SU showed some things to be excited about this past weekend. The new-look MeloHawk has clearly shown that he’s learned how to run. Joseph and Waiters had an excellent game and Triche and Fair both hit some clutch shots.

    I’d personally like to see Boeheim go deeper than a 7 man rotation. I think that will be essential in Big (l)East play and the tournaments when bench depth will help us muscle past one and two man teams.

    There’s a lot to be excited about this Men’s BBall season. I just wish I could get excited about it.

Leave a Reply